It Wasn’t Raining When Noah Built the Ark: Prepare for Family Business Quarrels Now
There’s no such thing as a family business without conflict. If you Google “family business feud,” in less than a second, you’ll get roughly 1.2 million hits. And that of course is the tiniest fraction of the number of family business disputes that do not show up in the Google search engines.
At their worst, a quarrel in the family business can become a threat to everything the family business holds dear, including relationships, wealth and position in the community. Seventy percent of family-owned businesses won’t make it to the next generation, and the biggest reason for this sad fact is family quarrels.
Since every family is going to have conflict, the fundamental question is, how do you deal with these quarrels so they don’t cause lasting damage?
Develop a Covenant CultureAn answer that has worked for many family businesses is to create a covenant culture. Do it long before it’s needed.
In a family business, this means that family members covenant with each other that while they have a right to air their disagreements, when a decision is made, they come together. They agree ahead of time to close ranks and move on.
Part of a covenant culture is, everyone gets to be heard. Participants agree to listen to all sides and to value robust discussion.
Another essential element — possibly the most important — is a commitment that issues will be resolved within the group. The reason for this is, in cases where members of a family business go to the media or get into litigation to resolve a conflict, they are likely to unleash an uncontrollable chain of events that predictably will endanger the entire family enterprise.
By the time a family business member exposes a conflict to the press or initiates litigation, there’s usually no turning back. The chances of reconciliation are so slim that many family business professionals will not take on as a client a family business that has reached this stage.
At this stage, when the family is in litigation or dueling it out in the press, chances are that family business is on its way to joining the 70 percent of family-run businesses that don’t make it to the next generation. What’s all important is preventing conflicts from reaching this stage.
Ways to Prevent Out of Control Family Business ConflictSince conflicts are inevitable, what can members of a family business do to support having a culture that commits to keeping quarrels within the family?
The answer is that the business family needs to consciously work on developing a culture for resolving conflict. Culture is, “How we do things,” and if the important work of developing a strong, supportive culture is left to chance, members of the family business may never learn key attitudes they’ll need to keep disputes from escalating. Without ways to keep conflicts from escalating, a covenant culture is not possible.
Developing a positive family business-friendly culture requires time together, discussions and above all, role modeling. To prevent disputes from getting out-of-hand, practice these six attitudes and techniques.
1. Take a moral stand that it’s wrong to move disagreements outside the family.The experience of many thousands of family businesses shows that once a family starts down the road of a public dispute or litigation, the usual end result is the end of the family business. Positions harden, reason goes out the window and it’s a rarity for any members of any family business to change course. The usual end point is either severe weakening of the business or its complete destruction. Members of business families need to know that it is morally wrong to be the cause of this.
2. Let family members know this isn’t just about their wishes.Because any public acrimony in a family business so often leads to the company’s failing, it threatens the well-being of innocent bystanders including the company’s employees, stockholders, lenders and even the tax base of the community. Members of family businesses need to know they have a responsibility to large numbers of people beyond themselves.
3. Emphasize the concept of “Family First.”Family businesses are unlike regular families, because in the tug of war between individualism and being a member of the group, there needs to be a different balance. Members of a family business have a different level of responsibility, because their actions influence all the stakeholders involved with the business.
4. Put relationships ahead of ego.Members of family businesses need to know that there are times when they have a choice between getting their way and having a relationship. Being a member of a family business at times means sacrifice, and for the business to continue, this can mean giving up the ego gratification of getting their way. However, in return they’ll get something of vastly greater importance — the chance for the family legacy to continue and thrive.
5. Compromise is key.Members of a family business need to learn to listen to each other, and they need to avoid the temptation to “stand on principle.” In the context of a family business, “standing on principle” is a synonym for “being stubborn.” It means, “I’m not going to listen to you.” It also tends to shut down discussion because virtue signaling can shut down the give-and-take that’s essential for compromise.
6. Be careful of what is said in anger.Angry words can be self-fulfilling; for example, disparaging someone’s competence or expressing preference for a sibling. A person may say something in momentary anger, but the person hearing what was said may remember those words for a lifetime. Garbage can come out of Pandora’s Box that can’t be stuffed back in again.
Done right, the family and all its benefits will endure. Done wrong, the family business blows up. By considering and practicing these six attitudes and techniques, you can quell any family business dissent before it jeopardizes the health of the company as a whole.